Knee and Meniscus Review
The review organizes the proposed meniscus target with your knee pain pattern, painful motions, treatment history, function, and written imaging report.
What goes into the review
The location and behavior of your symptoms are considered alongside the activities that reproduce them, the care you have tried, and the written report from your imaging.
When supported by the available information, the written review organizes areas that may deserve focused in-person evaluation before your next healthcare conversation.
For people who have not had knee surgery, whether surgery has been discussed or not.
For persistent symptoms after knee surgery or another surgery being considered in the same region.
You receive organized priorities, record gaps, and focused questions for your treating professionals.
Research in context
Each percentage describes a specific study population. Open the study details to see who was studied, what was measured, and how the result should be read.
assigned to exercise therapy did not cross to meniscus surgery within two years
Population: Middle-aged adults with MRI-verified degenerative meniscal tears and little or no radiographic osteoarthritis.
Finding in context: 19% crossed to surgery, without additional benefit. Exercise and partial meniscectomy produced no clinically relevant difference in knee function at two years.
Kise et al., BMJ, 2016 →assigned to physical therapy had not undergone meniscus surgery by two years
Population: 153 adults age 45 to 70 in the physical-therapy arm of the ESCAPE trial for degenerative meniscal tears.
Finding in context: 28.1% underwent surgery within two years. The model could not accurately predict who would cross over.
ESCAPE trial secondary analysis, 2021 →treated with physical therapy alone achieved a meaningful pain improvement at six months
Population: Adults age 45 or older with a degenerative meniscal tear and mild-to-moderate knee osteoarthritis in the MeTeOR trial.
Finding in context: A ten-point or greater pain improvement occurred in 73% who received physical therapy alone, 81% who crossed to surgery, and 82% assigned to surgery.
Katz et al., Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2016 →These findings concern degenerative tears. Acute traumatic tears, locked knees, repairable tears, and combined injuries may require a different discussion.
Meniscus repair preserves and fixes tissue when the tear and circumstances allow it. Partial meniscectomy or debridement removes damaged tissue. Your review uses the procedure named in the recommendation.
AAOS explains that meniscus surgery may involve repair or trimming and that the approach depends on the tear pattern, location, and other patient factors.
View source →Your detailed screening answers are processed locally in your browser and are not transmitted to Over the Knife. Only information you separately choose to submit through the contact or secure intake process is transmitted.
Start the Meniscus ScreeningSurgical decisions remain with you and your treating surgeon.